Currently I’m studying Heart Treasure of the Enlightened Ones with a Dharma friend, the Venerable Tashi Nyima.
This is my contemplation on the first line of verse 30 of the root text of Heart Treasure of the Enlightened Ones.

“Samsara is nothing other than how things appear to you;
If you recognize everything as the deity, the good of others is consummated.
Seeing the purity of everything confers the four empowerments on all beings at once;
Dredging the depths of samsara, recite the six-syllable mantra.”
Full Disclosure:
When I began this contemplation, it was my intent to do the first two lines. But as I started writing, I realized how much of our lives is dominated by appearances, so the contemplation turned out to be only on the first line.
Explain to someone else (making it my own)
When I was in my twenties, reality became wholly unconvincing. Something happened in my mind, some indefinable shift that made this world seem utterly insubstantial. It was an awareness that if I walked in front of a speeding car, it would surely hit me, but it shouldn’t because neither me nor the car were anything more than insubstantial ghosts.
Back then, living with this certainty day to day was pretty harrowing. I was afraid to tell anyone because it sounded so crazy. But crazy or not, I knew that the way I was perceiving things—insubstantial, ghostly apparitions—was how things truly were. After months of living with it, I finally had to ‘teach’ myself to believe and behave as though reality had a substantiality I knew it lacked. It didn’t really take. I never saw reality as completely solid ever again.
When I discovered (re-discovered?) Buddhism, it was a great relief. I didn’t have to pretend anymore. I’d been right all along. Samsara is a realm of continually generated reality that we have been generating for innumerable lifetimes. It may be the ultimate Dungeons and Dragons game. The only drawback is we’ve been playing the game for so many eons, we’ve forgotten it’s a game. We’ve forgotten we’re the Dungeon Masters.
Patrul Rinpoche puts it like this, “…not even a single atom has a verifiable existence….nothing that arises from causes and conditions has any true existence whatsoever….to see things otherwise, as truly existing, is the deluded perception underlying samsara…”. As we go through our ordinary lives, we accept reality without question. We accept that what we see is how things really are, and then we try to make things better. This is like a child building an elaborate sand castle on the sea shore. The tides are inevitable. They will come and wash away all that has been built. The tides of samsara—birth, age, disease, death—are no less inevitable. Anything we build here in samsara will soon be washed away by the unrelenting tides of this realm.
***
Apply to a past situation (how would it have been different?)
I think I was born a perfectionist. It’s certainly a karmic formation I came into this lifetime with. Until very recently in my life, I always wanted things to be…just so. It encompassed everything in my life, from my body to academics to relationships.
It was in the area of relationships that my drive for perfection caused the most suffering for me and those around me. Simply put, I wanted the perfect mother. I wanted Caroline from Little House on the Prairie. I wanted the mom on the Waltons. I wanted the mom on the Hallmark greeting cards, the one in all those sentimental paintings with such a look of beatific compassion, a faint halo practically shined over her head.
To put it succinctly, I never quite found the perfect relationship with my mother. After all these years, I’m finally coming to see that what I wanted, the relationship I thought would be ‘perfect’ was only an appearance in my mind. And even worse, it was someone else’s appearance, absorbed from screenplay writers and Hallmark hacks.
If I could have taken a step back from my angsty emotions around my mother, taken a few breaths to let peace and clarity arise, I might have noticed a few things. I may have noticed that the woman I always thought of as ‘my mother’ wasn’t my anything. She was a woman who’d given birth to the body my karmic formations were drawn into for this lifetime. If I could have noticed just that much, then my suffering would have decreased by orders of magnitude. I would have been able to see that my mother’s actions (or lack thereof) had absolutely nothing to do with me. She was hopelessly caught in the bindings of her own karmic formations, struggling to free herself, but only managing to become more and more entangled.
Having noticed this, I may have seen that the best thing for both of us would be to let go the appearances of ‘mother’ and ‘daughter’, and let go the incredible suffering it brought to hold on to appearances with a death grip.
***
Apply to an (ongoing) present situation (how does it matter today?)
The biggest ongoing situation in my life right now is silence. I know. Sounds funny, doesn’t it? A couple of weeks ago in his Dharma talk, my Dharma friend Tashi brought up silence and how we always have something on in the background. I immediately thought…yes, but it’s only Mozart or Beethoven. Someone else present brought up what I’d been thinking, and Tashi’s response really struck me. He said something like, “Yes. But silence is better.”
No, I thought to myself. That’s silly. That can’t be. But then I started really thinking about how little silence there was in my life. So I decided to take silence for a test drive through my life.
Wow! I lived in a noisy world. The first thing I used to do when I got home from work was turn on ocean sounds or tinkling
bells or an audio book. At work, I’d listen to music with lyrics. At night while I slept, ocean sounds had to be playing. Although I hadn’t done it in a while, I used to like ‘immersion reading’, meaning I’d listen to an audio book and read along. When I’d bake all day on Saturday, there would be a movie playing or a book or a Dharma talk.
So, these last two weeks I’ve experimented with silence. In that short time I’ve noticed so much in my life that I was doing based on appearances from almost a decade ago when I first got to Texas. Back then, I couldn’t bear to hear my own thoughts. There always had to be something drowning them out. I used New Age music, ocean sounds—whatever—anything so that I didn’t have to pay attention to my thoughts.
Until a couple of weeks ago, I thought I dreaded cleaning. I’d always turn on music or a book, to make it go by fast. But these last two weeks, I’ve discovered that I enjoy cleaning. I enjoy bringing order to my apartment. I especially enjoy cleaning the kitchen, and getting ready for weekend baking. There have been so many things in my life like that.
What I’m finding is that in the silence, the appearances of samsara take on a certain transparence. It’s not that things appear ‘ghostly’ like what happened when I was in my twenties, it’s just that things don’t appear wholly, convincingly solid. In a sense, all this silence lets me hear the churning gears of the clockwork of mind as it busily generates the appearances of samsara.
This has led to tangible changes in my life. I ended my subscription to Rhapsody, a digital music service. I suspended my Audible account. I have, in short, eliminated the two biggest noise engines in my life. As I continue this journey into silence, it feels like a fog is lifting from my mind and continually revealing, little by little, a perfect clarity that’s been there all along.
***
Apply to a potential situation (bringing it home to play)
Yesterday at work Interplanetary Title laid off three people. It turns out they have their own people who play with numbers, and so those three people had become suddenly expendable.
Ever since Interplanetary revealed their plan of conquest, their watchwords have been ‘growth’ and ‘expansion’. Without ever saying it, they implied that after years of surviving layoffs with the bank, our jobs were safe. Then this.
Yesterday at work there was a feeling of betrayal in the air. Although I didn’t hear anyone say it, I’m sure we were all, one way or another, thinking, “So…this is your idea of growth and expansion. Liars.” At work, as I thought about it back at my desk after the ‘re-organization meeting’, I experienced something that I’ve been taught again and again as I study the path. In samsara whenever you try to put your fears to rest based on phenomena, like a corporate takeover, you’re setting yourself up for suffering. It’s one thing to hear the teaching, but as always, another thing entirely to experience it in your life with clarity and attention.
I thought I had it all together with this whole transition thing. It’s samsara, I told myself, things won’t get better. They’ll for sure get worse. But ‘getting worse’ didn’t include not having a job. How could it after all that talk of growth and expansion? So, yesterday I experienced a sense of betrayal, of being lied to. I didn’t really start working with it until resentment began to creep in. I know how damaging that can be, so I started mantra, and I looked right at Mara until she slowly dissolved. It took hours of doing it again and again.
Today when I go to work, I will work with being a child of illusion. I will work with vigilantly reminding myself that whatever reality I encounter at work today is of my own making. Will there be desks and chairs and emails and a/c set to Arctic? Of course there will be. But more and more I’m coming to view those things as props on a stage. The play, the appearance that arises on the stage is entirely my choice. After all, it’s arising in my mind, created and given life by my karmic formations.
Today, I can choose to decrease my own suffering and that of others by not contributing to the fearful conversations that will come up. I can choose to act from a place of compassion rather than from a place of fear or resentment or anger.
I’m not sure what that looks like exactly, but I know that, just like me, every single being I encounter today will have Buddha Nature. And just like me, when someone resonates with who they truly are, the suffering will fall away, if only for a moment. So today I’ll go to the workplace looking for the light that shines in all sentient beings. In most, I probably won’t find it. We’re so good at hiding it, aren’t we? But I’ll sure have some interesting times looking for it.